I like to read about ass kicking and happily ever after.
I really loved the concept of this book, and I was 100% on board until about the last third when the author took a hard left turn from where I expected it to go. The ACTUAL direction the book went wasn't bad, was a mostly satisfying ending, but was definitely dissonant from my expectations. I liked Jace (and the audiobook narrator was good), and I'm curious to see where the series goes, so I'll at least go on to the next one.
I really struggled with what to rate this book. The prose was fine, I liked the heroine, and yet it wasn't at ALL what I expected from the summary. I kept thinking it would be a very obvious romance with a merman (and maybe a selkie, as much is made of the heroine's formerly webbed toes), so when I got to the end and the paranormal/fantasy aspect was never confirmed, never followed up on (I was SURE it would be a seal pelt in that trunk...), I found myself incredibly disappointed. Everything about the summary implies fantasy--not a contemporary YA romance set on an island that happens to have a lot of mythological sort of history. In the end, for a contemporary YA romance, it was sweet, and fun, with a nice setting. It just wasn't what I wanted.
In this compilation of three novellas, I really enjoyed the first one, which paired up some friends turned something more quite believably. The other two, while quirky and amusing (I really loved the town and its inhabitants) really pushed the bounds of my believability, resorting to Insta-love/lust that just didn't work for me. Still, the characters were a lot of fun, the love scenes steamy. I just wish there'd been a bit more emotional development to support said actions.
I found Melody really annoying as a heroine. I have the audio version, so I didn't notice the typos many other reviewers complained of, but in general, the fact that she didn't just break it off clean with before the story even started made me frown on her actions through the rest of the book. I have no patience for those who dilly dally with such things.